A B2B website redesign checklist: what to keep, what to change, what to measure

A website redesign should begin with what to keep: the URLs that bring in search traffic, the pages buyers read before they get in touch, and the tracking that tells you where leads come from. Then change the messaging, structure and design that no longer fit the business, redirect every old URL properly, and judge the result on enquiries, not on page views or compliments. The checklist below walks through each step for a B2B site.

When a B2B website redesign is the right call

Most companies redesign because they are embarrassed by the site, which is a fair reason but a poor brief. The useful reasons are more specific. The site describes what you sold five years ago. Your sales team hesitates before sending the link to a prospect. No one on the team can change a price or a job opening without filing a ticket with an agency. Enquiries arrive in a shared inbox and no one can say which pages or channels produced them. Or the company merged, rebranded or moved upmarket, and the site still speaks to the old buyer.

Some problems don't need a full B2B website redesign. If the structure works and only the words are stale, rewriting the main pages is faster and keeps everything that already ranks. If the site is slow but otherwise fine, a performance fix may do. A redesign earns its cost when the message, the structure and the way the site is built all need to change together, which is common for B2B companies that have grown out of their first site.

Before you change anything: measure the current site

A redesign without a baseline can't be judged afterwards, and the judgement then defaults to whether people like how it looks. Record these numbers first, ideally for the last twelve months so seasonality is visible:

• Enquiries per month, split by source (organic search, paid, referral, direct) and by form.
• The top landing pages and queries in Google Search Console, with clicks per page. Export them; you will need this list for redirects.
• Conversion rate on the pages that matter most, usually the homepage, the service pages and the contact page.
• Core Web Vitals for mobile and desktop.
• Which pages have links from other websites. Your SEO tool or Search Console's links report will show them.

Then ask the sales team two questions. Which pages do serious prospects read before the first call? And what do prospects ask on that call that the website could have answered? Those answers usually decide the new page structure more than any design trend does, and they cost nothing to collect.

What to keep from the old site

The instinct in a redesign is to start from a blank page. A lot of what the old site has earned is invisible, though, and a blank page throws it away. Keep these unless you have a clear reason not to:

• URLs that receive search traffic or links. Keep the same address where you can, and redirect where you can't.
• Content that ranks. If a page brings in qualified visitors, restructure it carefully and keep the substance that answers the query. Rewriting it from scratch to match a new tone is how rankings disappear.
• Pages your sales team sends. A pricing explainer or a technical spec sheet may look plain, but if it closes deals it belongs on the new site.
• Proof: real reviews, case studies, certifications and client logos you have permission to use.
• Integrations that work, such as the form that feeds the CRM, the newsletter signup and the booking tool, plus the tracking that records conversions.
• Recognisable brand elements, unless the redesign is part of a deliberate rebrand.

What to change in a B2B web design

B2B buyers rarely decide on the first visit. They come back several times, forward the link to a colleague, and look for reasons to rule you out: a vague description of what you do, no visible person behind the company, a contact form that feels like a black hole. Good B2B web design removes those reasons, so most of the changes worth making are about clarity before they are about looks.

• The first screen should say who you serve, what you do for them and why a buyer should believe you. Many older sites open with a slogan that could belong to any company.
• Put proof next to the claim it supports. A case study three clicks away from the service it proves does very little.
• Use a short page structure that matches how buyers think about your services, not your internal org chart.
• Make one clear next step per page, and make the contact form short. Ask only for what you need to reply well.
• Set the site up so your team can edit news, case studies, jobs and team pages without a developer.
• Make it fast on a phone. Plenty of buyers look up a supplier between meetings, and a design reviewed only on a large monitor can hide problems they will hit.

If the redesign includes a product or a logged-in area, the interface deserves its own attention; I cover that under UI and UX design for data-heavy products. For a single campaign or product launch, a focused landing page is often a better first project than a whole site.

Redirects and SEO: where a website redesign loses traffic

The most common way a website redesign hurts a business is in search traffic, and the cause is almost always the same: old URLs that stop working. A page that ranked for years starts returning a 404 error, and the ranking goes with it. Google's own guide to site moves with URL changes is clear about the fix:

1. Build a full list of old URLs from the sitemap, Search Console, analytics and your CMS, including PDFs and images that other sites link to.
2. Map every old URL to its closest new equivalent. Don't send everything to the homepage; Google advises against redirecting many old URLs to one unrelated page.
3. Use permanent server-side redirects (301 or 308), pointing straight to the final address without chains of hops.
4. Update internal links, canonical tags and the sitemap to the new URLs, so your own site doesn't rely on its redirects.
5. Keep the redirects for at least a year. Google suggests that as a minimum, and keeping them indefinitely does no harm.

Expect some movement in rankings while Google recrawls the site. The same guide says fluctuations are normal and that a medium-sized site can take a few weeks or longer to settle. What you should not see is a steady decline on pages that used to rank, because that usually points at a missing redirect or content that was cut.

The website redesign checklist, phase by phase

This is the order I would work in. The early phases are mostly writing and decisions, which is where most redesigns are won or lost.

1. Discovery: baseline numbers recorded, sales questions answered, URL list exported, a decision on what stays.
2. Messaging: who you serve and what you do, written down in a page before any design starts.
3. Structure: a page plan agreed, with every old URL mapped to a new one or a deliberate redirect.
4. Design: the homepage and one service page designed first and agreed, then the rest. Type, colour and spacing written down as a small system so later pages stay consistent.
5. Build: a preview link the whole team can click through on their own phones, with forms connected to the real CRM from the start.
6. Pre-launch: redirects tested from the full URL list, metadata and structured data checked, analytics and conversion tracking firing, every form submitted once.
7. Launch: the domain moved during a quiet period, the new sitemap submitted in Search Console, someone watching the error reports for the first days.
8. After launch: a check at two weeks and again at three months against the baseline.

What to measure after the redesign

Judge the new site on the numbers you recorded before you started. Enquiries per month by source come first, because that is what the site is for. Then conversion on the key pages, Search Console clicks for the pages that used to bring traffic, new 404 errors, and Core Web Vitals on mobile. Give it time. B2B sales cycles are long, and a month of data after launch says more about the redirects than about whether the new message works.

Two numbers mislead people after a redesign. Page views often rise simply because the new navigation sends visitors through more pages, and time on site can go either way for reasons that have nothing to do with quality. Neither tells you whether more of the right companies got in touch. If you want enquiries tracked from first visit to qualified lead, a small lead dashboard does the job; this concept lead generation report shows the kind of view I mean, on sample data.

Also check that the new site stays correct after the launch glow fades. Forms, tracking and integrations drift over the months that follow, which is what a website care plan is for.

Choosing website redesign services

When you compare providers, ask questions that reveal how they handle the parts above, not only how their portfolio looks. Who writes the copy, and do they talk to your sales team first? Do they handle the URL mapping and redirects themselves, and how do they test them? Will you own the domain, the hosting account and the code repository from day one? Can your team edit the pages they change most often without help? What happens after launch, and what does support cost?

A provider who answers those in specifics is probably going to protect what your current site has earned. One who moves straight to mood boards may still produce a beautiful site, but you will be the one checking the redirects.

I take on B2B sites only: consultancies, manufacturers, SaaS firms and specialist service providers. I start with structure and messaging, build on a stack you own, and handle redirects and tracking as part of the job. My page on B2B website design describes how a project runs, and if your site will later need a login area for clients, that can sit on the same codebase as a client portal.

Frequently asked questions